Finally occurrence of cavitation damage to the doosti dam spillway was investigated. Numerical and physical modeling of the effect of roughness. The upper part of the spillway surface matches closely to the profile of the lower nappe of a ventilated sheet of water falling freely from a sharpcrested weir. Cavitation potential of flow on stepped spillways journal.
How to determine the shape of an ogeecrested spillway and compute its discharge. The overflowing water is guided smoothly over the crest and profile of the spillway so that the overflow water does not break contact with the spillway surface. It belongs to overflow type spillway which contains a controlled weir and is ogeeshapedsshaped in profile. A 200ft wide excavated earthen emergency spillway is located through the north abutment figure 1. The study of cavitation phenomenon in the chute of jarreh dam by. Flow over a dam spillway prepared by redahegn sileshi 3 5. Although stepped spillways are thought to be less prone to cavitation damage than smooth spillways, designers continue conservative practices regarding specifying stepped. The experiments were conducted for different flow rates and the parameters of pressure, velocity. A curved approach channel leads to an ogee weir with three radial gates, followed by a transition section contracting the channel width, an open chute 20 m wide and some 176. Air entrainment and air demand in the spillway tunnel at. Feb 22, 2017 oroville dam was built in 1957 and they made the same kind of mistakes which created cavitation in its spillway during the unprecedented storms of february of 2017. Design of spillway aeration devices to prevent cavitation. Usually cavitation is the result of critical combination of velocity, pressure and vapor pressure.
Examples mahajanexamples mahajan an ogee spillway has 2. Likewise, cavitation and its effects on the discharge coefficient is also left. A section on design of spillways that considers cavitation and aeration. Spillwaypro is an excel spreadsheet implementation of the original dosbased computer programs distributed. The damaging effects of cavitation erosion may be reduced or stopped by decreasing the critical cavitation number e. The spillway is an ogee shaped weir divided into nine, 25ft wide bays and one 15ft wide bay figure 2. Pdf cavitation in chutes and spillways, engineering. A list of key technical references used for each major task involved with. Cavitation in chutes and spillways, engineering monograph no. The crest section for an uncontrolled ogee spillway is commonly shaped to conform to the underside of water flow over a weir.
Numerical detection of cavitation damage on dam spillway. In this paper, using flow 3d as cfd commercial tool, the cavitation phenomenon was assessed along spillway s flip bucket of the balaroud dam. Cavitation in chutes and spillways bureau of reclamation. Cavitation characteristics of high velocity flow with and without aeration on the order of 50 ms. This will produce a pressure distribution on the crest that is close to atmospheric pressure for the selected flow rate. Numerical prediction and risk analysis of hydraulic.
In this study, the ogeecrested spillways or overflow spillways discussed in this paper. Pdf spillways for medium and high head dams may be exposed to high velocity flows and the associated destructive phenomenon of cavitation. Spillways overflow spillways spillway crest profile the standard overflow spillway crest profile for a vertical upstream face is recommended by usbr 1987. Cavitation is a phenomenon in which rapid changes of pressure in a liquid lead to the formation of small vaporfilled cavities in places where the pressure is relatively low when subjected to higher pressure, these cavities, called bubbles or voids, collapse and can generate shock wave that is strong very close to the bubble, but rapidly weakens as it propagates away from the bubble.
Cavitation is, in many cases, an undesirable occurrence. In order to numerically predict the potential cavitation of a highspeed flow in a chute spillway, a compound risk assessment is proposed by combining probabilistic analysis with a computational fluid dynamics cfd technique. In this paper, using flow 3d as cfd commercial tool, the cavitation phenomenon was assessed along spillways flip bucket of the balaroud dam. Spillway design step by step 1st edition geraldo magela. Cavitation damage to concrete structures and its prevention. Ogee spillway is indicated through the following equation. Dec 12, 2014 in this method, to prevent cavitation damage on a spillway, it is necessary to keep the flow cavitation index higher than the cavitation inception index. Rhone bureau of reclamation po box 25007, d1530, denver, colorado usa 1988 summary.
Hoover dam spillways q clh university of minnesota. Cavitation in chutes and spillways spillwaypro can be used to analyze water surface profiles and cavitation characteristics of highvelocity spillway flows, develop optimized spillway profiles for new structures, design spillway aerators to prevent cavitation damage, and perform postevent cavitation damage assessments. This leads to cracks on the concrete surface which further increases the risk of damage to concrete by means of sulfate attack, freezethaw, alkalisilica reaction and other means. Ten foot high vertical lift gates are located in each of the 25ft wide bays and a skimmer gate is located in the 15ft wide bay. At first, flow over a spillway was simulated using the computational fluid dynamics method. Unesco eolss sample chapters hydraulic structures, equipment and water data acquisition systems vol. These experiences, combined with research on cavitation and alternative spillway designs, have refocused ideas away from requiring very smooth flow surfaces.
A hood provided over a conventional spillway forms a conduit. The characteristics of the spillway model are as follows. This study presents the results of physical and numerical modeling of the effect of bed roughness height of chute spillways on the cavitation index. Interestingly, ogee spillways can be designed to take advantage of suction of the nappe to the surface of the weir to get higher capacity than with a sharp crested weir, i. Presentation on chute spillways and bottom outlets, cavitation damage may occur at clear water velocities of between 12 to 15 ms. Prediction of cavitation damage on spillway using knearest. Pdf high velocities or abrupt changes in the flow direction may cause damages in hydraulic structures. Pdf cavitation in chutes and spillways researchgate.
P1, santhosh, y v g2, soma sekhar, s3 1associate professor, dept. There are four main components of a chute spillway. Based on cavitation index, five different damage levels from no damage to major damage have been considered. The present paper deals with the numerical detection of cavitation damage level and location on dam spillways. If this is not assured, a vacuum may form at the point of separation and cavitation may occur. Aug 19, 2019 spillway is a passage in a dam through which the design flood could be disposed off safely to the downstream. Oroville dam was built in 1957 and they made the same kind of mistakes which created cavitation in its spillway during the unprecedented storms. Cavitation damage to concrete structure surface is most common in case of spillway in dams. The crest of the spillway is shaped to conform to the lower nappe of a water sheet flowing over an aerated sharp crested weir. The type b spillway was a wes stepped spillway, with a smooth ogee crest and constant. The flowing water however, entrains air and once all the air in the crest area is removed, siphon action starts. Iii design of spillways and outlet works for dams m. Dec 23, 2016 numerical modeling of hydraulic phenomenon by computational fluid dynamic cfd approaches is one of the main parts in the high cost hydraulic structure studies.
Numerical modeling of cavitation on spillways flip bucket. An outline of the following chapters for this design standard that provides details for spillway and outlet works analysesdesigns. Prediction of cavitation damage on spillway using k. Prediction of cavitation damage for spillways journal of. In this paper, using flow 3d as cfd commercial tool, the cavitation phenomenon was assessed along spillways flip. Cavitation, stepped spillway of siahbishe dam, flow3dmodel. Cavitation damage has been a problem in tunnel spillways since 1941 when massive erosional damage was discovered at hoover dam. Examples of cavitation damage in dam spillways are well documented, and many efforts have been made to investigate the mechanism of damage.
The profile of the spillways is of ogee or s shaped. Flow over the crest of an overflow spillway is made to adhere to the face of the profile. The elements of a spillway are the inlet, the vertical curve section ogee curve, the steepsloped channel and the outlet. Partial gate open discharge performance for five dams with similar ogee, pier, and tainter gate geometry 46 50 54 58 62 66 70 74 78 82 86 90 94 98 102 106 0.
Ogee spillway is considered as the most suitable overflow type spillways. In order to avoid a hydraulic jump, the slope of the spillway must be steep enough for the flow to remain supercritical. Hydraulic cavitation is usually an undesirable phenomenon since it can damage the concrete surface of a chute spillway. Calculate mslope of the linear equation, lnkyintercept of the linear equation, k, and c. Jul 23, 2019 spillway is a passage in a dam through which the design flood could be disposed off safely to the downstream. Pdf the purpose of the monograph is to give the designer of hydraulic structures both an understanding of cavitation and the tools necessary. Research on step spillway designs has prompted the idea that designing in very large roughnesses in the form of steps may yield benefits not only for energy dissipation but also for. Depth of flow at the toe of spillway is measured equal totoe of spillway is measured equal to 0. Physical and numerical model studies on cavitation. Model investigations of the gojeb spillway ethiopia 2002. Noah shares about the erosional process of cavitation at glenn canyon dam, where solid rock was quickly cut with high pressure water and quick.
Spillway definition, types of spillways and classification. The head above the spillway crest is the design head hd. Results showed that the spillway may be at the risk of cavitation damage, and the serious damage can occur at ending parts of the structure. In this study, considering the spillway geometry and equations the ruling the fluid flow on spillway, the modification of spillway profile is evaluated so that the cavitation index would be constant across the and structure greater than its critical value.
An ogee crest is a common control structure shape for sewice spillways, including. Design principles that are involved in the design of flow. Pdf reduce spillways cavitation damages through accurate. Spillwaypro can be used to analyze water surface profiles and cavitation characteristics of highvelocity spillway flows, develop optimized spillway profiles for new structures, design spillway aerators to prevent cavitation damage, and perform postevent cavitation damage assessments. The study of cavitation phenomenon in the chute of jarreh.
Reduction the risk of cavitation phenomenon in dam. An ogee spillway has a control weir whose profile is as shown in fig. Mar 19, 2015 noah shares about the erosional process of cavitation at glenn canyon dam, where solid rock was quickly cut with high pressure water and quick flow. The spillway is an ogeeshaped weir divided into nine, 25ft wide bays and one 15ft wide bay figure 2. Computational modeling of flow over an ogee spillway.
Physical and numerical model studies on cavitation phenomenon. Jun 06, 20 cavitation on spillways has proven to be an undesirable condition. Stepped chute is located after a low slope chute in downstream of ogee spillway. With the rise in reservoir level water starts flowing over the crest as in an ogee spillway. In devices such as propellers and pumps, cavitation causes a great deal of noise, damage to components, vibrations, and a loss of efficiency. Pdf cavitation in chutes and spillways semantic scholar. Performance of numerical modeling was compared to the physical model, which was. Cavitation damage has been a problem in tunnel spillways since 1941 when massive erosional damage was discovered at.
Cavitation in bureau of reclamation tunnel spillways clifford a. Shand encyclopedia of life support systems eolss where v approach velocity m s1 y approach depth m g 9. The ogee spillway is generally provided in rigid dams and forms a part of the main dam itself if sufficient length is available. Pdf reduction of cavitation on spillways by induced air entrainment. Cavitation has also become a concern in the renewable energy sector as it may occur on the blade surface of tidal stream turbines. As the name indicates, this spillway works on the principle of a siphon.
Types of spillways ogee spillway definition spillway. Physical and numerical model studies on cavitation phenomenona study on nagarjuna sagar spillway rajasekhar. It has a control weir that is ogee or sshaped the structure divides naturally into three zones. Ogee overflow spillway the ogee or overflow spillway is the most common type of spillway. Spillway is a passage in a dam through which the design flood could be disposed off safely to the downstream. The formation of vaporfilled bubbles and cavities and their eminent collapse has led to significant damage to major spillway components and appurtenant structures worldwide. Although much research about cavitation and the resulting damage has been conducted for more than 30 years, existing methods for predicting cavitation damage on spillways are incomplete. Cavitation damage on a spillway is a very complex process. Crest piers placed on overflow spillways induce standing waves at. Investigation ofcavitation in stepped spillway of siah. Numerical modeling of hydraulic phenomenon by computational fluid dynamic cfd approaches is one of the main parts in the high cost hydraulic structure studies. Reduction the risk of cavitation phenomenon in dam spillway. Localized high velocity and large elevation range design strategy for the concrete ogee spillway. Chute spillways carry supercritical flow through the steep slope of an open channel.
1316 221 1366 202 1323 1442 541 1343 890 1402 1486 1326 298 153 1296 26 609 1004 547 728 508 397 694 161 240 163 694 908 248 767 1378 458 612 375 602 664 1256 359 351 1344 655